My family and I absolutely love this stovetop beef stew. I’ve been making it for years and making slight changes here and there to really perfect the recipe. This is a fully from-scratch way to make beef stew. You don’t need any pre-made broth and I don’t use cornstarch.
This is one of the first recipes that I will make as soon as the temperatures start to drop in the fall and I make it all winter long. You definitely have to make this on a day that you’re going to be home all day because it cooks for so many hours on the stove. Don’t be scared off by the length of cooking time. For three and a half hours of the cooking time, your stew will be covered and simmering on low and won’t need to be touched at all. I know that a lot of people like to make beef stew in the Crockpot, but I threw mine away after that episode of This is Us (if you’ve seen it, you know) and I never looked back.
I want to share some of my tips and suggestions that I’ve learned from making this so many times, in hopes that it will save someone from making the same mistake or mistakes that I’ve made. Be very careful when adding your stew beef to the pot with hot oil. I have had so many mishaps with this and I’m pretty experienced in the kitchen. I’ve dumped it in too fast and had the oil splash up and burn me several times. My other beef mishap is when I try and dump it into the pot directly off of the Styrofoam container and for some reason, I will manage to dump the absorbent pad that’s beneath the beef right into my pot and then it’s a disaster. So don’t do that. Gently add the beef in handfuls or spoonfuls even if you feel the urge to dump it and run.
Another live and learn lesson that I’ve lived and learned is that if you forget to take the Bay leaves out of the pot before adding your veggies, you will have a much harder time finding and removing them. So be sure to take them out after that first hour and a half simmer and before the veggies.
If you’re reading this recipe and feeling like it’s an overload of onions, just trust the process. It is a lot of onions, but they liquefy along with the garlic and become broth. You won’t be able to pick an onion out of this stew once it’s done. The onions and the garlic make for a flavorful broth so that you don’t need to use canned or boxed broth.
I hope that you try this and love it! If you like soup, but don’t have the time to dedicate to this one, try my roasted sausage soup, it’s really good too!
This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase after clicking a link, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Discover more from Best Little Moments
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.















This stovetop beef stew recipe sounds like it’s been perfected with love and experience! It’s wonderful that you’ve taken the time to fine-tune it over the years, creating a fully from-scratch version that doesn’t rely on pre-made broth or cornstarch. Your dedication to crafting this hearty dish really shines through, and I can see why it’s such a beloved meal for your family. Thank you for sharing this tried-and-true recipe—it’s a true testament to comfort and tradition!
HI! Thank you so much! I’m so glad that you enjoyed the stew. One of the things that I love most about it is that the broth thickens up on its own without corn starch. I’m so glad that you like that too! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave a review.
Sarah
Stove Top vs slow cooker…. The veggies aren’t all mushy but distinct flavors come through. I agree with Nanajee’s compliments, you have produced and written this recipe with much love and consideration. Helping new cooks not burn themselves is testimony to positive awareness. Thanks for postin. Also, interesting video… so short and to the point if you know something about sauté & simmer!
Hi Amy Lee! Thank you so much! I have burned myself one too many times recklessly adding my stew beef to the pot lol! You’re totally right about the video being short. My videos are more for instagram and TikTok so that I can promote my recipes there. Hopefully someday when I can hire an assistant, I can do additional filming that can show more of the cooking and baking process. That would be really fun! I’m glad you enjoyed the stew and appreciate you taking the time to comment.
Sarah